The Murder of Betsy Faria: Part Two
Sources:
https://allthatsinteresting.com/pam-hupp
https://time.com/6156033/the-thing-about-pam-renee-zellweger-true-story/
https://www.stlmag.com/longform/pam-hupp/
https://www.stlmag.com/news/defense-attorney-joel-schwartz-charles-bosworth-new-book-bone-deep-true-crime-betsy-faria-pam-hupp/
https://people.com/pam-hupp-charge-refiled-betsy-faria-stabbing-death-8384298
https://www.ksdk.com/article/news/crime/pam-hupp-may-not-be-tried-for-betsy-farias-murder-until-2028/63-fc0923af-96e0-409a-84d3-bc585dba3ef3
https://fox2now.com/news/fox-files/pam-hupp-trial-delayed-but-unexpected-encounter-outside-highlights-day/
https://insurancenewsnet.com/oarticle/Russell-Farias-wife-was-stabbed-55-times-but-was-he-the-killer-a-471968
Speaker 1: Warning. Kind of Murdery contains adult themes, explicit language, and
Speaker 1: descriptions of violence. It is not suitable for anyone, and
Speaker 1: we recommend you stop listening now.
Speaker 2: True Crime with a dash of the paranormal, the garish,
Speaker 2: the strange in the darkly comic. A podcast that's about
Speaker 2: more than just murder. It's my very own pocket dimension,
Speaker 2: home to a curated collection of bizarre and compelling stories,
Speaker 2: the unsolved, the unsettling, and the unbelievable. I cover it
Speaker 2: all just so long as it's kind of murdery.
Speaker 3: Listen. I've just started reading this book. It's called A
Speaker 3: Little Bit Bad. Like Assandra Niosh, she's known mostly for
Speaker 3: her short fiction published in The New Yorker. This book,
Speaker 3: A Little Bit Bad is published by Summit Books, and
Speaker 3: it came out yesterday, that's right, came out yesterday May fifth.
Speaker 3: So I've just started reading it and I couldn't help
Speaker 3: myself because listen, it's set in my hometown of San Diego,
Speaker 3: and it's protagonist is obsessed with true crime. So she
Speaker 3: has an affair and then years later her firstwhile lover
Speaker 3: is murdered and everything starts to get even wilder from there. Anyway,
Speaker 3: I'm loving it, but like I said, it came out
Speaker 3: yesterday and I just started it, so I haven't gotten
Speaker 3: far enough to give a real review that I can
Speaker 3: stand behind yet, but would definitely recommend so far, And
Speaker 3: by next week I should be done and can give
Speaker 3: you guys a real review. And if I like it
Speaker 3: as much as I think I will, then I'm going
Speaker 3: to try to get Cassandra on the show for an interview,
Speaker 3: which I think would be awesome. But if you're willing
Speaker 3: to trust my just started it, liking it so far review,
Speaker 3: then check out a little Bit Bad by Cassandra Naiush
Speaker 3: or wait until next week when you get the real review.
Speaker 3: And if I like it and you guys think it
Speaker 3: sounds cool, then we'll get Cassandra on the show and
Speaker 3: talk to her about the book and her inspirations and
Speaker 3: all kinds of other stuff. I'm sure she's a fascinating woman.
Speaker 3: She's certainly a great writer. Oh that's right, I am
Speaker 3: zevn Odleberg. Hello. Hello, this is kind of murdery welcome.
Speaker 3: Thank you so much for being here. As I say
Speaker 3: every week, I appreciate it deeply that you choose to
Speaker 3: spend your valuable time with me. All right, let's jump
Speaker 3: straight into the story. This is part two, that's right,
Speaker 3: I said part two. So if you haven't listened to
Speaker 3: part one yet, go back and listen to it and
Speaker 3: then come join us. I'll save you a seat. But
Speaker 3: this is part two of kind of Murdery's examination of
Speaker 3: the murder of Betsy Faria, and it starts now. The
Speaker 3: first deputies through the front door found Russ Feria standing
Speaker 3: near the edge of the living room with a phone
Speaker 3: still pressed against his ear. The dispatcher's voice could be
Speaker 3: heard faintly through the receiver while officers stepped past him
Speaker 3: and into the house. One deputy moved directly toward Betsy
Speaker 3: on the floor beside the couch, while another stopped with
Speaker 3: Russ near the injury, keeping him back with a hand
Speaker 3: lightly held against his arm. What happened, asked the deputy.
Speaker 3: Russ looked past the deputy toward the living room before answering, aye, aye,
Speaker 3: I came home and found her like that. The deputy
Speaker 3: asked if anyone else was inside the house. Russ shook
Speaker 3: his head once and said no. His breathing still came
Speaker 3: fast between answers. Blood had dried in streaks across one
Speaker 3: hand and along the front of his pants, where he'd
Speaker 3: wiped his palm earlier without thinking about it. The deputy
Speaker 3: near Betsy crouched low beside the body, taking the room
Speaker 3: in piece by piece before touching anything. The living room
Speaker 3: stayed quiet except for radios, footsteps, and the dispatcher still
Speaker 3: talking faintly through Russ's phone. Betsy lay beside the couch
Speaker 3: where Russ had found her, one arm angled awkwardly near
Speaker 3: her side. Blood spread beneath her into the carpet. The
Speaker 3: knife protruding from her neck remained untouched. A deputy leaned
Speaker 3: in close, checking for signs of life, while another officer
Speaker 3: stood back near the hallway, watching the rest of the house.
Speaker 3: Russ kept turning his head toward Betsy while the questions
Speaker 3: continued around him. What's your name, Russ forarrhea? How long
Speaker 3: were you gone tonight? A few hours? Where were you
Speaker 3: with friends? The deputy writing notes asked Russ to repeat
Speaker 3: the names of his friends slowly while he wrote them
Speaker 3: down one at a time. Russ rubbed both hands against
Speaker 3: his genes between answers, leaving darker smears where blood still
Speaker 3: hadn't dried completely near the front door. Another officer started
Speaker 3: bogging everybody entering the house. Paramedics came through the doorway
Speaker 3: carrying equipment bags, stepping carefully. Once officers pointed out the
Speaker 3: blood near the couch, one knelt beside Betsy, while the
Speaker 3: other paused just long enough to study the scene around
Speaker 3: her first, the position of the body, the knife, the
Speaker 3: amount of blood already soaked into the carpet fibers. Their
Speaker 3: voices stayed low while they worked. Russ stood near the
Speaker 3: dining area, now separated from the center of the room
Speaker 3: by two deputies. He kept looking toward the paramedics while
Speaker 3: an officer continued questioning him. When was the last time
Speaker 3: you saw your wife alive before I left to night?
Speaker 3: She was home resting after her treatment. What time did
Speaker 3: you leave? Around six? The deputy wrote steadily, without looking
Speaker 3: up much, while Russ answered. Every few seconds, Russ shifted
Speaker 3: his wad or craned his neck slightly, trying to see
Speaker 3: past the officers moving around the living room. One deputy
Speaker 3: noticed and quietly told him to stay where he was.
Speaker 3: Russ nodded and stayed planted beside the dining table. Outside,
Speaker 3: patrol cars lined the street in front of the house,
Speaker 3: red and blue lights washing across near by garages and
Speaker 3: parked cars. Neighbors had started gathering near driveways in front walks,
Speaker 3: bundled in jackets against the cold, while watching officers move
Speaker 3: in and out through the open front door. Every time
Speaker 3: the door opened, wider voices and radio traffic spilled briefly
Speaker 3: out into the neighborhood before the sounds softened again. Inside,
Speaker 3: investigators started photographing the living room before anything was moved.
Speaker 3: One crouched near the floor, taking wide shots of the couch, carpet,
Speaker 3: and blood spread around Betsy's body. Another stood farther back,
Speaker 3: photographing the room from corner angles before moving closer for
Speaker 3: tighter shots. Flash after flash lit the walls white for
Speaker 3: an instant. Russ watched part of that from the kitchen
Speaker 3: entrance while another deputy continued asking questions, Did you touch
Speaker 3: the knife? No? What did you touch her shoulder? I
Speaker 3: checked her neck. The deputy asked him to describe exactly
Speaker 3: where he had put his hands. By then, the house
Speaker 3: had divided into separate pockets of activity happening at once.
Speaker 3: Patrol officers controlled the front injury while paramedics stayed near
Speaker 3: Betsy and investigators worked the living room floor around them.
Speaker 3: Detectives had started arriving too, walking into the house more
Speaker 3: slow slowly than the first responders had, stopping near the
Speaker 3: body to study the scene before speaking much at all.
Speaker 3: One detective finally sat across from Russ at the dining
Speaker 3: table and started again from the beginning. What time did
Speaker 3: you get home? Russ answered? What did you do when
Speaker 3: you walked in? I called for her, then I found her.
Speaker 3: The detective watched Russ carefully while he spoke, occasionally glancing
Speaker 3: down at his notes. When you found her, what did
Speaker 3: you do first? I touched her shoulder. I thought maybe,
Speaker 3: I thought maybe she was still alive. Behind them, another
Speaker 3: camera flash lit the living room again, while evidence markers
Speaker 3: began appearing near the couch and across the bloodstained carpet
Speaker 3: around Betsy's body. The detectives kept Russ at the dining
Speaker 3: table while the scene team worked through the house room
Speaker 3: by room. Questions were repeated in slightly different ways each
Speaker 3: time a new investigator sat down across from Russ. Where
Speaker 3: had he parked when he arrived home, Which room had
Speaker 3: he entered first, Whether any doors had been locked when
Speaker 3: he came inside? Russ answered each question while rubbing his
Speaker 3: hands together or wiping them again against his genes without
Speaker 3: seeming to notice he was doing it. One detective asked
Speaker 3: him to walk through the evening from the beginning. Russ
Speaker 3: said Betsy had been home after chemotherapy, resting while he
Speaker 3: left to meet his friends. He described leaving for the
Speaker 3: weekly gathering, then returning home later that night and calling
Speaker 3: out for her after he came inside. What made you
Speaker 3: go into the living room, asked the detective. Well, I
Speaker 3: couldn't get her to answer me. The detective wrote that
Speaker 3: down immediately. In the living room, investigator's photographed everything before
Speaker 3: collecting it. One technician worked slowly around the bloodstained carpet,
Speaker 3: placing numbered markers beside visible evidence, while another took close
Speaker 3: up photographs from different angles near the couch. The knife
Speaker 3: still protruding from Betsy's neck remained untouched while they documented
Speaker 3: the position of the body and the surrounding room. An
Speaker 3: investigator near the hallway photographed a pair of slippers with
Speaker 3: blood on them before placing markers nearby. Another technician crouched
Speaker 3: load of photograph stains leading across part of the carpet
Speaker 3: near the living room area. Every movement inside the room
Speaker 3: stayed deliberate. Officers stepped carefully around evidence markers and avoided
Speaker 3: the blood spread beneath Betsy. From the dining area, Russ
Speaker 3: could still see pieces of the activity through gaps between
Speaker 3: investigators moving around the house. Detectives began reaching out to
Speaker 3: the friends Russ had said he had been with that evening.
Speaker 3: Names from the game night group had already been written
Speaker 3: down during the first interviews. Inside the house, officers worked
Speaker 3: phones near the kitchen while another detective continued talking to
Speaker 3: Russ across the table. What time did you leave your
Speaker 3: friend's house? Uh, I don't know exactly. Did anybody leave
Speaker 3: with you? No? The detective asked him again about finding Betsy.
Speaker 3: When you saw her, What did you think happened? Russ
Speaker 3: looked down at his hands before answering, Ah, I don't know.
Speaker 3: I just saw the knife and all the blood. One
Speaker 3: investig gator entered briefly from the living room and quietly
Speaker 3: handed the detective another sheet of notes before stepping back
Speaker 3: out toward the crime scene area. Outside, the neighborhood remained
Speaker 3: awake long past when the street usually went dark. Patrol
Speaker 3: car lights continued flashing across lawns and garage doors, while
Speaker 3: officers moved between the house and their vehicles carrying equipment, bags, cameras,
Speaker 3: and evidence containers. Neighbors stayed gathered in small groups near
Speaker 3: the curbs, speaking quietly while watching the activity around the
Speaker 3: Faria home. Inside, the temperature of the house had shifted,
Speaker 3: with the front door constantly opening and closing. Cold air
Speaker 3: moved through the injury way every time another officer came inside.
Speaker 3: A detective finally asked Russ if he needed water. Russ
Speaker 3: nodded once, and a deputy brought him a bottle from
Speaker 3: the kitchen. He twisted the cap off slowly, hands still
Speaker 3: stained dark along the fingers and knuckles. Across the room,
Speaker 3: another camera flash lit the hallway white for a split second.
Speaker 3: As the interviews continued, detectives started narrowing the timeline surrounding
Speaker 3: Betsy's last known hours alive. They asked Russ again about
Speaker 3: the chemotherapy appointment, about Pam Hump driving Betsy home afterward,
Speaker 3: and about the text Betsy had sent earlier that evening,
Speaker 3: saying Pam had brought her home to bed. Russ answered
Speaker 3: each question while detectives compared his statements against notes already
Speaker 3: collected from the house and phone records beginning to come in.
Speaker 3: Did you speak to Pam tonight? No? When was the
Speaker 3: last time you saw her? Earlier before I left? The
Speaker 3: detective kept writing while another investigator moved through the dining room,
Speaker 3: carrying sealed evidence bags out through the front door from
Speaker 3: deeper in the house. The sound of cameras clicking and
Speaker 3: officers speaking quietly to each other continued without stopping. By
Speaker 3: the early hours of the morning, the house had taken
Speaker 3: on the rhythm crime scenes often due after the first
Speaker 3: rush settles down, Fewer people talking at once, more quiet movement,
Speaker 3: investigators crossing the same rooms repeatedly checking details they had
Speaker 3: already looked at once before. Evidence bags lined part of
Speaker 3: the dining area table, while photographs continued in the living
Speaker 3: room around Betsy's body. Russ remained seated near by while
Speaker 3: detectives kept working through the timeline again from the beginning.
Speaker 3: What time did Pam leave the house? I don't know
Speaker 3: exactly what was Betsy wearing when you left? Russ paused
Speaker 3: before answering, eyes drifting toward the living room again. I
Speaker 3: I don't remember. The detective watched him for a second
Speaker 3: before writing something down. One investigator focused on documenting blood
Speaker 3: evidence throughout the living room area. Another photograph spots near
Speaker 3: the hallway and portions of the floor surrounding the couch
Speaker 3: from different angles, before kneeling lower for close up shots.
Speaker 3: The pair of slippers investigators had marked earlier remained near
Speaker 3: the edge of the room while technicians continued photographing them
Speaker 3: before A detective stepped carefully through the scene and stopped
Speaker 3: near the couch, studying the room without speaking for several seconds.
Speaker 3: His eyes moved from the blood stains to the knife,
Speaker 3: and then toward the surrounding furniture behind him. Another investigator
Speaker 3: quietly said, there's a lot here. The detective nodded once,
Speaker 3: without looking away from the scene. Across the room, the
Speaker 3: sound of a camera shutter clicked again and again. Russ's
Speaker 3: friends had begun speaking with investigators by then, confirming that
Speaker 3: Russ had been with them earlier in the evening. During
Speaker 3: the regular game night gathering, detectives moved between conversations inside
Speaker 3: the house and phone calls with witnesses outside it, building
Speaker 3: timelines on legal pads and notepads scattered across the dining table.
Speaker 3: One detective returned to Russ with another series of questions
Speaker 3: when you found her, did anything in the room look disturbed?
Speaker 3: I wasn't looking at the room. I was looking at her.
Speaker 3: Did you move anything besides touching her? No. The detective
Speaker 3: asked him to describe exactly where he had knelt beside Betsy.
Speaker 3: Rust leaned slightly forward in the chair while explaining, one
Speaker 3: hand unconsciously rubbing at the dried blood still visible near
Speaker 3: his wrist. Elsewhere in the house, investigators began collecting items
Speaker 3: that had already been photographed and documented evidence. Technicians moved slowly,
Speaker 3: changing gloves repeatedly while sealing objects into bags and labeling
Speaker 3: them before carrying them out through the front door. The
Speaker 3: knife remained in place while the rest of the room
Speaker 3: continued to be processed around it. Near the kitchen, one
Speaker 3: investigator quietly discussed the timeline involving Pam Hupp driving Betsy
Speaker 3: home after chemotherapy. Another detective reviewed notes involving Betsy's text
Speaker 3: message sent earlier that evening. Betsy texted Pam Hup wants
Speaker 3: to bring me home to bed? She offered and I accepted.
Speaker 3: The detective re read the line once more while comparing
Speaker 3: time stamps written beside it in his notes. Behind him.
Speaker 3: Another officer carried additional evidence bags towards the entryway. As
Speaker 3: the night continued, detectives kept returning to the same basic
Speaker 3: questions surrounding the final hours before Betsy's death. Who had
Speaker 3: seen her last, who had spoken to her, who had
Speaker 3: been inside the house? Russ answered each round of questions,
Speaker 3: while the activity around him never fully stopped. Officers moving
Speaker 3: through doorways, radios crackling softly, investigators stepping carefully around the
Speaker 3: taped off living room. One detective finally closed his notebook
Speaker 3: for a moment and looked directly at Russ. We're going
Speaker 3: to keep working through everything tonight. Russ nodded once from
Speaker 3: the living room. Another burst of camera flashes briefly lit
Speaker 3: the hallway while investigators continued documenting the scene around Betsy's body.
Speaker 3: By morning, detectives had started pulling together the first full
Speaker 3: timeline of Betsy's last day alive. Notes covered tables inside
Speaker 3: the house and continued into patrol cars parked outside. Times
Speaker 3: were written down, crossed, then rewritten as investigators compared statements
Speaker 3: against phone records and witness interviews. The chemotherapy appointment sat
Speaker 3: near the center of everything because it established where Betsy
Speaker 3: had been earlier that day and who had been with her.
Speaker 3: Pam Hupp's name appeared repeatedly in the notes. Detectives confirmed
Speaker 3: that Pam had driven Betsy home after treatment. They also
Speaker 3: had the text message Betsy sent Russ that evening, Pam
Speaker 3: Hup wants to bring me home to bed. She offered
Speaker 3: and I accepted. One detective circled the time stamp beside
Speaker 3: the message, while another copied it into a separate report.
Speaker 3: Investigators also focused heavily on Russ's movements that evening. Detectives
Speaker 3: spoke again with the group of friends Russ said he
Speaker 3: had been with during the game night, comparing each account
Speaker 3: against the others to see whether the timelines matched. The
Speaker 3: interviews happened separately, different conversations, different officers, The same basic
Speaker 3: questions repeated over and over. What time did Russ arrive?
Speaker 3: What time did he leave? Did he leave at any
Speaker 3: point during the night. The friends described the gathering as routine,
Speaker 3: the same kind of night they'd held many times before, games, movies,
Speaker 3: food spread out on tables while people moved in and
Speaker 3: out of conversations. Over the course of the evening. Detectives
Speaker 3: wrote down each detail, carefully checking times against phone activity
Speaker 3: already being pulled into reports. Back at the house, investigators
Speaker 3: continued processing the living room around Betsy's body. Crime scene
Speaker 3: technicians worked methodically through the physical evidence. Blood stains across
Speaker 3: the carpet were photographed repeatedly before measurements were taken. The
Speaker 3: slippers marked earlier in the investigation remained part of the
Speaker 3: evidence being documented. Inside the living room, detectives moved slowly
Speaker 3: around the scene while technicians pointed out specific areas they
Speaker 3: wanted preserved in photographs before collection. One investigator crouched near
Speaker 3: the couch, reviewing images on the back of a digital camera,
Speaker 3: while another dictated observations quietly into a recorder. Knife still
Speaker 3: in place, blood saturation extending outward from the victim evidence
Speaker 3: marker's positioned near footwear nearby. Another technician carefully sealed collected
Speaker 3: items into evidence bags, while an officer logged each piece
Speaker 3: before it left the house. The living room lights stayed
Speaker 3: on the entire time. Detectives began interviewing Pam Hup in
Speaker 3: greater detail about her time with Betsy that day. Pam
Speaker 3: described driving Betsy home after chemotherapy and leaving afterward. She
Speaker 3: also repeated statements she already had made about Betsy's marriage,
Speaker 3: telling investigators Betsy had expressed fear of Russ and described
Speaker 3: him as verbally abusive. Detectives documented those statements carefully because
Speaker 3: they directly affected how the investigation was beginning to take shape.
Speaker 3: One investigator compared Pam's timeline against the text message Betsy
Speaker 3: had sent earlier that evening, while another reviewed notes from
Speaker 3: Russ's interview conducted overnight. Pam's account placed Betsy alive after
Speaker 3: returning home from treatment and before Russ left for game night.
Speaker 3: A detective underline part of that timeline in his notebook.
Speaker 3: As the investigation expanded beyond the house itself, officers started
Speaker 3: collecting additional records tied to Betsy and Russ's daily lives,
Speaker 3: phone records, financial information, contact lists. Detectives built timelines across
Speaker 3: legal pads and whiteboards while comparing witness statements against time
Speaker 3: stamps from calls and messages. Inside those conversations, the same
Speaker 3: names kept surfacing Russ, Pam, Betsy's friends, the game night group.
Speaker 3: One detective re visited Russ's statements from the night before
Speaker 3: and paused at the line where Russ described finding Betsy
Speaker 3: beside the couch. Another investigator nearby reviewed photographs from the
Speaker 3: scene while listening. In the living room, technicians were still
Speaker 3: working around the bloodstained carpet, while detectives continued building the
Speaker 3: first working theory of what happened inside the house. The
Speaker 3: detective assigned to Russ's interview had stopped writing for a
Speaker 3: while and started watching instead. Russ sat at the dining
Speaker 3: table under the kitchen light, with a bottle of water
Speaker 3: in front of him, cap off barely touched. Every so often,
Speaker 3: he rubbed his palms against his jeanes, again smearing what
Speaker 3: remained of the dried blood across the fabric near his knees.
Speaker 3: The house had gone quieter by then. Most of the
Speaker 3: patrol officers who had crowded the rooms earlier were outside
Speaker 3: or working elsewhere, leaving only the low murmur of investigators
Speaker 3: and the occasional burst of radio traffic drifting in from
Speaker 3: the front doorway. A detective flipped back a few pages
Speaker 3: in his note book. You said Betsy was resting when
Speaker 3: you left, Russ nodded once. What exactly do you mean
Speaker 3: by resting? She was tired from chemo, She was laying down.
Speaker 3: Did she say anything before you left? Russ looked down
Speaker 3: toward the table before answering, no, nothing unusual. The detective
Speaker 3: the silence, sit there for a few seconds before asking
Speaker 3: his next question. In the living room, investigators were still
Speaker 3: working around the body. One technician crouched beside the couch
Speaker 3: photographing small areas of carpet, while another stretched a measuring
Speaker 3: tape across portions of the floor near the blood stains.
Speaker 3: The camera flashes came slower, now spaced farther apart than before,
Speaker 3: each burst briefly whitening the walls and ceiling before the
Speaker 3: room settled back into a steady lamplight. The detective stood
Speaker 3: near the edge of the room, holding a stack of
Speaker 3: photographs already printed from earlier shots. He compared the images
Speaker 3: against the room in front of him, eyes moving between
Speaker 3: the blood stains, the couch cushions, the knife still protruding
Speaker 3: upward from Betsy's neck. Another investigator stepped carefully around an
Speaker 3: evidence marker and stopped beside him. What are you seeing?
Speaker 3: The detective lowered one of the photographs, slightly a lot
Speaker 3: of blood for a suicide. Neither man spoke for a
Speaker 3: few seconds while they kept looking at the room. Back
Speaker 3: at the dining table. Another detective had joined the interview.
Speaker 3: He carried a fresh notebook and a styrofoam cup of
Speaker 3: coffee that smelled burnt the second he set it down.
Speaker 3: He didn't sit immediately. Instead, he stood beside the table,
Speaker 3: looking over the earlier notes, while Russ waded across from him.
Speaker 3: You and your wife having problems, Russ exhiled through his nose,
Speaker 3: before answering, everybody has problems, and that's not what I asked.
Speaker 3: Russ shifted in the chair, glancing once toward the living
Speaker 3: room before looking back. We argued sometimes, how bad? Normal bad.
Speaker 3: The detective finally sat down, then flipping open the notebook slowly,
Speaker 3: while the other detective watched Russ overfolded arms. Outside, another
Speaker 3: set of headlights swept briefly across the kitchen window before
Speaker 3: fading away again. From deeper in the house came the
Speaker 3: sound of another evidence bag being sealed shut. Pam Hupp's
Speaker 3: earlier statements were already circulating among detectives inside the house.
Speaker 3: Printed notes from her interview sat clipped to a legal
Speaker 3: pad near the kitchen counter, while one another investigator re
Speaker 3: read portions allowed quietly to another. Betsy, afraid of Russ,
Speaker 3: Russ verbally abusive, Betsy worried about money. The investigator reading
Speaker 3: paused occasionally to underline lines with the cap of his pen,
Speaker 3: while the other detective listened across the room. Russ kept
Speaker 3: answering questions. When was the last time you? And Betsy argued,
Speaker 3: I don't know this week? Probably what about? Russ rubbed
Speaker 3: one hand against his forehead and stared at the table
Speaker 3: a second before answering, I don't remember, the detective wrote, anyway.
Speaker 3: Near the hallway entrance, an evidence technician walked past carrying
Speaker 3: several sealed bags, while another investigator photographed the slippers again.
Speaker 3: The longer the night went, the more the investigation settled
Speaker 3: around the assumption that the answers were already somewhere inside
Speaker 3: the house. Detectives moved slower, now, less urgency in their footsteps,
Speaker 3: more time spent standing still and studying details before speaking.
Speaker 3: Investigator remained near the couch almost continually, occasionally kneeling to
Speaker 3: examine something near the floor before standing again and quietly
Speaker 3: discussing it with the others near by at the dining table.
Speaker 3: The questioning narrowed further. Did Betsy ever threaten suicide? No?
Speaker 3: Did she seem depressed to night she was sick tired.
Speaker 3: The detective watched Russ carefully after each answer, waiting to
Speaker 3: see whether anything changed in his face, before moving on
Speaker 3: to the next question. In the living room, the knife
Speaker 3: still remained where investigators had first found it, surrounded now
Speaker 3: by evidence markers, camera equipment, and the dark stains spreading
Speaker 3: through the carpet beneath Betsy's body. Near dawn, the house
Speaker 3: had settled into that strange, exhausted quiet that crime scenes
Speaker 3: sometimes reach after everyone has been awake too long. Coffee
Speaker 3: cups sat half finished on counters and inn tables, jackets
Speaker 3: hung over chair backs. Detectives moved more slowly through the
Speaker 3: room now, not because the work had stopped, but because
Speaker 3: they were looking harder at smaller things. A camera flash
Speaker 3: still went off now and then from the living room,
Speaker 3: but long stretches passed in between, with only the sound
Speaker 3: of low voices and shoes crossing the floor carefully. At
Speaker 3: the dining table, one detective flipped through a stack of
Speaker 3: notes while another reviewed photographs spread out beside him. Russ
Speaker 3: remained in the same chair he'd been sitting in for hours.
Speaker 3: Shoulders slumped now, voice rougher Each time he answered another question,
Speaker 3: the detective tapped one of the photographs lightly with his pen.
Speaker 3: Walk me through exactly what you touched? Again. Russ leaned
Speaker 3: forward slightly in the chair, elbows near his knees, eyes
Speaker 3: fixed on the table while he answered, I touched her
Speaker 3: shoulder first with which hand my right? Then what I
Speaker 3: checked her neck? The detective kept writing steadily while another
Speaker 3: investigator nearby compared Russ's answers against earlier notes taken closer
Speaker 3: to me midnight. Every so often, one of them stopped
Speaker 3: to ask for clarification about where Russ had been standing
Speaker 3: or how close he'd gotten to the body before kneeling
Speaker 3: beside her. Across the room, investigators continued working around the
Speaker 3: living room floor. The blood had darkened further as it
Speaker 3: dried into the carpet fibers beneath Betsy. One technician crouched
Speaker 3: near the couch studying the edge of the stain, while
Speaker 3: another photographed sections of the room, now cleared of earlier equipment.
Speaker 3: The knife still remained in place while they documented the
Speaker 3: final details around the body. Pam Hupp's statements kept resurfacing
Speaker 3: throughout the night's conversations between detectives. Printed interview summaries had
Speaker 3: been copied, highlighted, and passed from one investigator to another.
Speaker 3: As the hours wore on. One detective stood near the
Speaker 3: kitchen counter, re reading portions quietly under his breath, while
Speaker 3: another leaned beside him, listening. She said Betsy was afraid
Speaker 3: of him. She also said Betsy talked about money. The
Speaker 3: second detective took the papers and scanned them himself while
Speaker 3: looking toward the dining room, where Russ still sat answering questions.
Speaker 3: Near By, another investigator reviewed the text message Betsy had
Speaker 3: sent earlier that evening about Pam bringing her home to
Speaker 3: bed after treatment. The time stamp beside the message had
Speaker 3: been circled several times in dark ink. From outside, came
Speaker 3: the muffled sound of another patrol car door shutting. Inside
Speaker 3: the living room, investigators had finally begun preparing for the
Speaker 3: removal of Betsy's body. Before anything changed, more photographs were
Speaker 3: taken from multiple angles around the couch and surrounding floor.
Speaker 3: One detective stood with folded arms near the hallway entrance,
Speaker 3: watching silently while technicians documented the knife, the blood patterns,
Speaker 3: and the position of Betsy's body. One final time before
Speaker 3: movement disturbed the scene. The room looked crowded with evidence markers.
Speaker 3: By then, a technician near the couch spoke quietly to
Speaker 3: another investigator, careful around the right side. The second investigator
Speaker 3: adjusted his footing, immediately stepping around the edge of the
Speaker 3: blood stain while carrying additional evidence bags toward the dining area.
Speaker 3: Camera flashes reflected briefly across the living room windows each
Speaker 3: time another photograph was taken at the table. Russ looked
Speaker 3: up when the flashes went off, then lowered his eyes again.
Speaker 3: The detectives questioning Russ had narrowed almost completely on to timing.
Speaker 3: By then, they revisited the sequence repeatedly. Chemotherapy, appointment, Pam
Speaker 3: driving Betsy home, Russ leaving for game night, Russ returning
Speaker 3: to the house. The same names and times moved in
Speaker 3: circles across pages of notes spread over the dining table.
Speaker 3: One detective pointed at the notebook in front of him.
Speaker 3: You're sure nobody else had a key to the house,
Speaker 3: Russ answered, quietly, not that I know of. The detective
Speaker 3: wrote that down, then immediately followed with another question. When
Speaker 3: you came into night, was anything missing? No? Anything out
Speaker 3: of plate? Russ paused longer, this time staring toward the
Speaker 3: living room before answering, I I wasn't looking at the room.
Speaker 3: I saw Betsy. From the other side of the house.
Speaker 3: Came the sound of investigators beginning the careful process of
Speaker 3: moving evidence out toward waiting vehicles, as daylight slowly started
Speaker 3: appearing through the windows near the kitchen. By morning, detectives
Speaker 3: had moved beyond the first wave of emergency response and
Speaker 3: into the slower work of deciding what kind of case
Speaker 3: they believed they were Standing inside, the house looked different
Speaker 3: in daylight. The flashing patrol lights that had washed across
Speaker 3: the walls overnight were gone, now replaced by gray morning
Speaker 3: light coming through the windows and falling across the same rooms.
Speaker 3: Investigators had spent hours walking through evidence. Tapes still crossed
Speaker 3: portions of the living room, while technicians carried equipment in
Speaker 3: and out through the front door. One detective stood near
Speaker 3: the kitchen counter flipping through photographs taken over night, while
Speaker 3: another reviewed interview notes beside him. The pages were already
Speaker 3: crowded with names, times, arrows, underlined phrases. Russ sat at
Speaker 3: the dining table again while detectives resumed questioning him. After
Speaker 3: only a short break when you left for game night?
Speaker 3: Was Betsy already in bed? No resting on the couch?
Speaker 3: I think so, the detective wrote something down immediately. The
Speaker 3: living room had become the center of nearly everything investigator's discussed.
Speaker 3: Detectives drifted back toward it repeatedly, even while talking elsewhere
Speaker 3: in the house, Standing near the couch and quietly comparing
Speaker 3: observations with each other, one investigator crouched beside the carpet
Speaker 3: studying photographs, while another looked directly at the room itself,
Speaker 3: comparing the images against the physical scene in front of him.
Speaker 3: The knife had finally been removed by then and logged
Speaker 3: into evidence, but the outline of the scene remained unchanged
Speaker 3: around the couch. Dark blood stains still spread through the
Speaker 3: carpet fibers beneath where Betsy's body had been. A detective
Speaker 3: near the hallway spoke quietly to another investigator, you think
Speaker 3: in homicide. The second detective didn't answer immediately. He kept
Speaker 3: looking at the room a few seconds longer before speaking,
Speaker 3: I'm thinking this doesn't look right. Neither detective raised his
Speaker 3: voice above conversation level. Investigators continued tightening the timeline surrounding
Speaker 3: Russ's evening with his friends. Detectives re interviewed members of
Speaker 3: the game night group separately, comparing details about arrival times,
Speaker 3: movies watched, food ordered, and when Russ had finally left
Speaker 3: for home. Legal pads filled with overlapping timelines sat spread
Speaker 3: across the dining room table while officers checked phone records
Speaker 3: against the statements being collected. One detective, reading through the notes,
Speaker 3: paused near a line and tapped it with his pen.
Speaker 3: He says Russ was there basically the whole night. Another
Speaker 3: investigator looked over his shoulder, what about gaps? Nothing obvious yet.
Speaker 3: The detective circled one of the listed times while another
Speaker 3: officer nearby worked through outgoing calls connected to the group
Speaker 3: from earlier that evening. The smell of stale coffee and
Speaker 3: damp winter air lingered through the house while investigators moved
Speaker 3: slowly between conversations. Near the front door, an evidence technician
Speaker 3: carried another sealed container out toward a waiting vehicle. Pam
Speaker 3: Hupp remained central to the timeline investigators were building. Detectives
Speaker 3: reviewed her statements repeatedly because she was one of the
Speaker 3: last known people to see Betsy alive. Her account placed
Speaker 3: her driving Betsy home after chemotherapy, helping her get settled,
Speaker 3: and leaving before Russ departed for game night. Investigators compared
Speaker 3: her timeline against phone records, text messages, and Russ's own
Speaker 3: statements from the night before. One detective re read Betsy's
Speaker 3: text message aloud while another checked the time stamp beside it.
Speaker 3: Pam hup wants to bring me home to bed, she offered,
Speaker 3: and I accepted. The detective holding the phone records, underline
Speaker 3: the time with a pen and puts Pam there after
Speaker 3: treatment and before four Russ leaves near by. Another investigator
Speaker 3: reviewed Pam's statements about Betsy being afraid of Russ, while
Speaker 3: quietly adding notes into the margin of the report. The
Speaker 3: more detectives worked the scene, the more their attention stayed
Speaker 3: fixed on the possibility that the answers were already inside
Speaker 3: the house somewhere. Investigators revisited the slippers with blood on them.
Speaker 3: They reviewed photographs of the bloodstains around the couch. They
Speaker 3: compared Russ's movements inside the house against the positions documented
Speaker 3: by crime scene technicians overnight. One detective sat across from
Speaker 3: Russ again later that morning while flipping through the growing
Speaker 3: stack of reports. You understand why we keep asking the
Speaker 3: same questions, Russ nodded tiredly, Yeah, I understand. The detective
Speaker 3: leaned back slightly in the chair. Right now, we're trying
Speaker 3: to figure out exactly what happened in this room. Behind him,
Speaker 3: another investigator carried a fresh stack of printed crimes i'me.
Speaker 3: Scene photographs into the kitchen, while daylight continued spreading through
Speaker 3: the house, where detectives had now spent the entire night
Speaker 3: working around Betsy's death. As the morning wore on, investigators
Speaker 3: started narrowing their attention toward details they believed supported a
Speaker 3: violent confrontation inside the house. Detectives moved slowly through the
Speaker 3: living room, again, stopping near the couch, then stepping back
Speaker 3: to study the room from wider angles before returning to
Speaker 3: the same spots. One investigator held a stack of scene photographs,
Speaker 3: while another pointed towards sections of blood stained carpet near
Speaker 3: the edge of the living room. Look at the spread here.
Speaker 3: The second detective crouched lower, studying the stain pattern, before
Speaker 3: answering quietly, doesn't stay contained from the dining area. Russ
Speaker 3: watched investigators move around the room, while another detective continued
Speaker 3: writing notes beside him. The repeated interviews with Russ had
Speaker 3: started producing pages of overlapping statements. By then, detectives compared
Speaker 3: earlier answers against newer ones line by line, occasionally circling
Speaker 3: details or writing short notes in the margins besides specific times.
Speaker 3: One investigator flipped through several pages before stopping near the
Speaker 3: middle of the stack. You said earlier that you called
Speaker 3: for Betsy twice before seeing her, Russ, not at once.
Speaker 3: I think so, You think so? Or you did? Russ
Speaker 3: rubbed his forehead before answering I did. The detective wrote
Speaker 3: something down while another investigator across the room reviewed photographs
Speaker 3: from the scene. At the same time, every answer Russ
Speaker 3: gave now was being matched against earlier notes, time stamps,
Speaker 3: and physical evidence collected inside the house. The questioning stayed calm,
Speaker 3: but the pauses between questions had grown longer. Detectives also
Speaker 3: continued re visiting Pam Hupp's statements throughout the day. Printed
Speaker 3: summaries from her interviews remained spread across portions of the
Speaker 3: dining table, beside photographs, records, and handwritten timelines. One investigator
Speaker 3: re read sections describing Betsy's fear of Russ, while another
Speaker 3: reviewed notes tied to the insurance policy discussions Pam claimed
Speaker 3: Betsy had mentioned during her treatment appointments. A detective near
Speaker 3: the kitchen quietly said, she's giving us motive. Another investigator
Speaker 3: looked back toward Russ before answering, or she thinks she is.
Speaker 3: The first detective didn't respond right away. He continued scanning
Speaker 3: the pages in front of him, while the second detective
Speaker 3: picked up Betsy's text message again and re read the
Speaker 3: line about Pam bringing her home after treatment. Outside, daylight
Speaker 3: had fully replaced the flashing patrol lights from earlier in
Speaker 3: the night. Inside the living room, investigators had started removing
Speaker 3: larger pieces of evidence from the scene. Technicians carried sealed
Speaker 3: containers through the house one at a time, while detectives
Speaker 3: documented where each item had originally been found before it
Speaker 3: left the room. The couch remained in place, surrounded by
Speaker 3: evidence markers and sections of blood stained carpet that investigators
Speaker 3: continued photographing before collection. One technician knelt near the floor,
Speaker 3: trimming sections of carpet around specific stains, while another carefully
Speaker 3: labeled bags at a folding table set up near the hallway.
Speaker 3: The room smelled sharply of cleaning chemicals, latex gloves, stale air,
Speaker 3: and dried blood. A detective standing near the couch glanced
Speaker 3: toward another investigator and said, quietly, this wasn't quick. The
Speaker 3: other detective kept his eyes on the floor while answering no.
Speaker 3: Camera shutters continued clicking through the room while technicians worked.
Speaker 3: By later that afternoon, the investigation had begun shifting from
Speaker 3: simple scene processing into theory. Building Detectives gathered around dining tables, counters,
Speaker 3: and the hood of patrol cars outside, comparing notes from interviews,
Speaker 3: evidence collection timelines, and phone records. Russ's account remained central
Speaker 3: to nearly every conversation because he had discovered the body
Speaker 3: lived in the house and had been gone during the
Speaker 3: estimated window. Investigators were trying to define. One detective reviewing
Speaker 3: notes finally closed the folder in front of him and
Speaker 3: looked toward another investigator nearby. You think he's lying. The
Speaker 3: other detective crossed his arms before answering, I think we
Speaker 3: keep digging. Inside the house, investigators were still moving carefully
Speaker 3: through the living room, photographing the last remaining sections of
Speaker 3: the scene, while the evidence gathered during the night and
Speaker 3: morning continued leaving the house peace by peace. By late afternoon,
Speaker 3: the investigation inside the house had started settling into something
Speaker 3: more focused. Earlier in the day, the rooms had been
Speaker 3: crowded with patrol officers, paramedics, and people moving quickly from
Speaker 3: one task to another. The urgency had burned off hours ago.
Speaker 3: Now the movement inside the house looked slower and more deliberate.
Speaker 3: Detectives stood still longer before speaking. Investigators returned repeatedly to
Speaker 3: the same sections of the living room floor, crouching beside
Speaker 3: stains they had already photographed twice before. Notes had spread
Speaker 3: across the dining table in loose stacks, crime scene photographs,
Speaker 3: interview summaries, phone logs, legal pads, filled with timelines written
Speaker 3: and re written. As the day progressed, Russ remained at
Speaker 3: the dining table while investigators continued working around him. He
Speaker 3: looked exhausted by then. His shoulders sagged lower into the
Speaker 3: chair than they had earlier in the morning, and the
Speaker 3: answers he gave detectives came more slowly, now separated by
Speaker 3: longer pauses. The dried blood still visible near his hands
Speaker 3: had darkened against the skin over the course of the day,
Speaker 3: As the afternoon continued, fewer discussions inside the house revolved
Speaker 3: around whether Betsy had been killed. Most of the conversation
Speaker 3: had already moved beyond that point. Detectives were now comparing timelines, behaviors,
Speaker 3: blood evidence, and witness statements against the growing theory taking
Speaker 3: shape inside the house. The shift had happened gradually, rather
Speaker 3: than all at once. The longer investigators stayed inside the house,
Speaker 3: the more attention they paid to Russ himself. While he
Speaker 3: sat under questioning, detectives compared his movements against the physical
Speaker 3: layout of the scene repeatedly throughout the afternoon. One investigator
Speaker 3: reviewed photographs showing the blood on Russ's clothing, while another
Speaker 3: worked through the timeline surrounding the nine one one call
Speaker 3: and Russ's description of finding Betsy beside the couch. Russ
Speaker 3: occasionally looked toward the living room whenever investigators crossed through
Speaker 3: it carrying evidence or photographs. At times, he sat completely
Speaker 3: still for long stretches, hands clasped together near the edge
Speaker 3: of the table, while detectives quietly compared notes near by
Speaker 3: without including him in the conversation. The atmosphere inside the
Speaker 3: house had changed from active emergency response into something narrower
Speaker 3: and heavier. Detectives no longer moved like people searching blindly
Speaker 3: through possibilities. Their questions had become more specific, their conversation shorter.
Speaker 3: More time passed in silence while they reviewed reports and
Speaker 3: studied photographs already collected from the scene. Outside. Daylight had
Speaker 3: started fading from the neighborhood again. At the dining table,
Speaker 3: Russ sat largely alone now while detectives moved in and
Speaker 3: out of the kitchen carrying files and photographs. Conversations around
Speaker 3: him had changed tone over the course of the day.
Speaker 3: Earlier discussions had focused on understanding the scene. By evening,
Speaker 3: most of the investigators inside the house sounded like people
Speaker 3: trying to organize evidence around a conclusion they believed they
Speaker 3: had already reached. Outside. Patrol car lights flashed silently across
Speaker 3: the windows while the investigation continued building around Russ inside
Speaker 3: the house. One detective finally gathered the growing stack of
Speaker 3: reports from the dining table and carried them into the kitchen,
Speaker 3: where several investigators had been quietly comparing notes for most
Speaker 3: of the evening. The room had gone nearly silent except
Speaker 3: for pages turning, camera equipment being packed away in the
Speaker 3: low crackle of radio traffic drifting in from outside. Russ
Speaker 3: remained seated alone at the table while the detectives stood
Speaker 3: together only a few feet away. Photographs and timelines spread
Speaker 3: between cups of cold coffee, and legal pads filled edge
Speaker 3: to edge with notes. Nobody in the kitchen sounded uncertain anymore.
Speaker 3: One detective tapped a photograph from the living room with
Speaker 3: the end of his pen. Another flipped open a notebook
Speaker 3: and re read part of Pam Hupp's statement. A third
Speaker 3: investigator compared time stamps from phone records against the timeline
Speaker 3: they'd spent the last several hours rebuilding piece by piece
Speaker 3: inside the house. One of the detectives looked back toward Russ,
Speaker 3: sitting alone at the table, and quietly said, we need
Speaker 3: to lock this down before he lawyers up. Nobody in
Speaker 3: the room disagreed. Outside, the patrol lights continued flashing across
Speaker 3: the windows, while detectives inside the house began discussing the
Speaker 3: next steps and building a murder case against Russ Faria
Speaker 3: and we'll stop there. Please join me next week Wednesday,
Speaker 3: May thirteenth, for Part three of Kind of Murdery's investigation
Speaker 3: of the murder of Betsy Faria, and also an update
Speaker 3: on Cassandra NIOSH's new murder mystery set in San Diego,
Speaker 3: A little Bit Bad. I'm Zevan Oldberg and this has
Speaker 3: been kind of Murdery.
Speaker 1: If you like the show, please subscribe, review and tell
Speaker 1: your friends. You can find us on social media at
Speaker 1: kinda Murdery or email at Kindomurdery at gmail dot com
Podbean